Canadians rushing to lock down five-year fixed rate mortgages

Economists predict more interest rate hikes are on the way, making this mortgage option attractive—and smart

If you’re renewing a mortgage this month, chances are you will do so at the five-year fixed rate. At least, that’s what the numbers by show. Consumers are rushing in droves to lock in five-year fixed mortgage rates ahead of future Bank of Canada rate hikes.

“Historically, the majority of Canadians who shop for mortgage rates have taken a variable rate the majority of the time,” says Dan Eisner, CEO of True North Mortgage in Calgary. “But not these days.”

Since January 2014, 56% of Canadian borrowers who applied for a mortgage through have gone variable, compared with 43% of those who got a five-year fixed. But this past August, there was a shift, where the five-year-fixed rate mortgage saw a sharp increase in applicants, with 59% of users on the site opting for this option versus only 39% opting for the variable mortgage.

READ: That was probably it for interest rate hikes in Canada for a while

“The spread between the variable and fixed rate mortgages has shrunk substantially since the Bank of Canada rate hike earlier this month,” says Eisner. Most people weren’t expecting the move but now the five-year fixed rate looks more attractive, he adds. “The variable rate is always lower but the question is, ‘by how much?’”

And while not all banks have increased their five-year mortgage rates yet, they may all do so by Friday. “By looking at long-term bond rates, it looks like the five-year fixed rate will go up between 0.1% and 0.15% by the end of the week…So if I were personally getting a mortgage, today is a good day to get the five-year fixed rate,” says Eisner.

Still, Justin Thouin, co-founder and CEO of crunched the numbers and notes, “Based on the past 30 years, staying in a variable-rate mortgage is still the right choice in the long run if your goal is to pay as little interest as possible.”

From a historical perspective, the variable mortgage rate is often lower, meaning homeowners pay less in interest overall. But it might be worth it to pay a little more for a fixed rate for the next five years, in case interest rates rise dramatically.

Indeed, Eisner doesn’t foresee interest rates going back down anytime soon. For one, he notes that the economy is strong and likely will keep strengthening over the next two years. And even though the difference between the rates on today’s five-year fixed and the five-year variable is razor-thin right now, that spread is likely to widen as the economy picks up steam and more interest rate increases are announced.

MORE: Why didn’t markets see the Bank of Canada interest rate hike coming?

Eisner’s recommendation? Go for the five-year fixed term at today’s rate and aim to pay off your mortgage in under 10 years by making a concerted effort to make extra payments whenever you can.

“They almost all come with 10% or 20% annual prepayment options—whether you do it on the anniversary of the mortgage or throughout the year,” he says. If you’re diligent with repayment strategies, you can double up your payments and shorten your 25-year amortization schedule down to five or seven years. “The only time you see prepayment options missing is with super low rates so avoid those. It’s often worth paying a fraction more for the prepayment privileges.”

What’s the bottom line? Even though the five-year variable rate has historically been a popular option, economists generally agree that interest rates are set to steadily climb over the next few years. For that reason, locking in a five-year fixed rate—though a bit higher than the variable rate right now—is the smart move. “You’ll have the peace of mind of knowing your mortgage rate is at these low rates for five years at least so that you can concentrate your efforts on paying it down quicker,” says Eisner.

Looking for more?

Get the Best of Maclean's sent straight to your inbox. Sign up for news, commentary and analysis.