Why does Andrea Horwath want to eat the rich?

Ontario’s top 1 per cent earns 12 per cent of all income, but pays its fair share of 26.5 per cent of all income tax

Mark Milke is author of Tax Me I’m Canadian! A Taxpayer’s Guide to Your Money and How Politicians Spend It.

“Elections are no time to discuss serious issues,” said former prime minister Kim Campbell in the midst of the 1993 election campaign. (Campbell, and the Progressive Conservative government she inherited from Brian Mulroney, would go on to lose the election in a wipeout, winning just two seats.)

Campaigns for public office are precisely the time to discuss such matters, but I understand why politicians are loath to dive into specifics while vote-seeking: facts might contradict their own unsupportable platform assumptions.

The latest example is playing out in the Ontario provincial election. NDP leader Andrea Horwath’s platform demands that “the wealthiest people…pay their fair share” of tax.

WATCH: Why a simple math mistake (and Bob Rae) could cost the NDP the Ontario election

Horwath’s assumption is that higher-income Ontarians do not now pay their fair share. She proposes higher income taxes on that group. But let’s examine her assumption with clear data that address the true, relative tax burdens for Ontarians by income level.

The data comes from my own 2017 study for the Canadian Taxpayers Federation, Who Pays Income Tax? The data is from the CRA and includes all income tax paid for the 2014 tax year (the most recent year available when I wrote the study).

Here’s what I found for Ontario by tax filers and Ontario provincial income taxes paid, for 2014:

  • In Ontario, those earning less than $50,000 constituted 67.6 per cent of all tax filers, earned 30.4 per cent of all income, and paid 11.6 per cent of all Ontario provincial income tax.
  • Those earning between $50,000 and $100,000 comprised 23.8 per cent of tax filers, earned 35.6 per cent of all income, and paid 31.6 per cent of Ontario income taxes.
  • Those earning over $100,000 constituted 8.6 per cent of tax filers, earned 34.0 per cent of all income, and paid 56.8 per cent of Ontario’s provincial income taxes.

Add middle and high-income earners together, and those earning more than $50,000 constituted 32.4 per cent of all tax filers in 2014, earned 69.6 per cent of all income, and paid 88.4% per cent of all Ontario income taxes.

READ: Andrea Horwath makes her play to displace the Liberals among Ontario’s left

For the record, even for those who earned less than $50,000 (more than 3.7 million Ontarians), 52 per cent paid all the income tax; 48 per cent (nearly 3.3 million Ontarians) paid nothing, understandably, due to lower incomes.

The summary: Out of nearly 10.4 million returns filed in Ontario in 2014, nearly 7.1 million Ontarians—low, middle and high income—paid all provincial income tax; almost 3.3 million paid zero in provincial income tax, most with less $50,000 in income.

One response to this is that income tax collections do not tell the whole story.

After all, Ontario has a provincial sales tax (included in the Harmonized Sales Tax) and Ontario health premiums.

True, but the health premiums cost nothing at lower levels of income (under $20,000) but progressively more the higher one’s income. As for sales taxes, the same dynamic applies; Ontarians receive sales tax credits when they file their income tax returns, where low and moderate income tax filers get a break.

Back to Horwath: The NDP leader’s plans for higher income taxes (another 1 per cent higher at $220,000 and 2 per cent more over $300,000) will push Ontario’s top marginal rates to 55.43 per cent, higher even than the present highest marginal rates in the country, in Nova Scotia (at 54 per cent).

READ: Just how far can Andrea Horwath go?

By the way, break out those who earn $250,000 or more in Ontario and we see they constitute 1 per cent of all Ontario tax filers. Their share of all income in 2014 was 12 per cent. They paid 26.5 per cent of all provincial income tax.

That Horwath thinks higher-income earners do not already pay their “fair share” says much about her motivation: class warfare, not reasoned analysis of the tax system.

The big picture: When 3.3 million Ontarians pay nothing in provincial income taxes and little in health care premiums and sales taxes, here’s another way to look at yet another eat-the-rich tax proposal: Middle-income and higher-income Ontarians already pay for most of the cost of the government in Ontario.

READ: An unimpeachable source lobs an unavoidable bomb into Ontario’s election

“Low-income Ontarians get a great, tax-free deal for the cost of government” is not a campaign plank with which a political party based in class warfare rhetoric would be comfortable.

But it happens to be a clear fact.


Looking for more?

Get the Best of Maclean's sent straight to your inbox. Sign up for news, commentary and analysis.