On Campus

Inch shouldn’t have to fund the student union

Ottawa student lost bid to have student fee returned


I don’t like my student union’s Education is a Right campaign and I don’t go to social events on campus like the Winter Challenge. I don’t need the transit pass and don’t generally associate myself with the politics of my student union at the University of Ottawa, where I study part-time. So why should I have to pay to be a member?

Edward Inch didn’t think he should have to pay and so he tried suing the Student Federation at the University of Ottawa (SFUO) in small claims court for the $92.60 they charged him one semester after he opted out of the union in 2012.

In a court decision yesterday, deputy judge Lyon Gilbert decided Inch must pay up anyway. “As a student, Mr. Inch is bound to the terms and conditions of enrollment,” Gilbert said, according to The Fulcrum student newspaper.

Gilbert may not support Inch’s argument, but I do. I don’t agree with SFUO’s political causes and I don’t use the services, so why should almost $100 come out of my pocket to pay for it?

The SFUO, like most other student federations, has services that are useful for many students. Our federation provides us with a health plan, U-Pass and social events. But I only make it to campus once or twice per week at best, I already have a health plan and I can’t use the U-Pass. The $90 I could use. I’d much rather spend it on a year’s supply of ramen or a communications textbook.

It’s also a matter of principle for me, as it was for Inch. The SFUO is extremely politically charged and doesn’t hide it. They hosted a National Day of Action against tuition fees last year, gathering students from across the country to protest. With a float, a DJ, and professional banners, I bet it cost students a pretty penny. Last year I asked how much it cost but never got an answer.

SFUO also spent at least $1,000 to rent a coach bus to shuttle about 50 protesters to protest in Toronto during the G20 summit in 2010. If I want to support a political cause like that, I would find a way. My student federation should focus on improving the student experience—and that’s it.

To opt out of one’s student union should be an option, as should be getting a refund. I don’t pay for a drink with my Big Mac if I don’t want the drink. I don’t want to join a student union when I pay my tuition; I just want to complete my degree. It’s too bad Inch didn’t get his money back.

Jane Lytvynenko (@JaneLytv on Twitter) is Ottawa bureau chief of the Canadian University Press.

Looking for more?

Get the Best of Maclean's sent straight to your inbox. Sign up for news, commentary and analysis.