Gas station owners pitched an alternative to Ford’s carbon-tax stickers

But the provincial Tories rejected the suggested pie charts that would’ve shown everything that goes into the cost of filling up

Faced with the Ontario Conservative government’s plan to force gasoline retailers to slap stickers on their pumps showing the cost of the federal Liberal government’s carbon tax, the association that represents the owners of more than half of the gas stations in Canada found that proposal “a bit partisan” and suggested a less politicized alternative.

Instead of the stickers Premier Doug Ford’s government is imposing this month—flagging how the federal carbon tax adds 4.4 cents per litre now and is slated to rise to 11.1 per litre cents in 2022—the Canadian Independent Petroleum Marketers Association (CIPMA) suggested a voluntary pie chart sticker, which would have shown everything that goes into the price of gas.

Jennifer Stewart, the CIPMA’s president and chief executive officer, said in an interview that her association made the proposal in talks with the Ford government late last year. “We were told they were looking at a sticker—they were quite upfront about that,” Stewart said. “We actually proposed an option to the government that disclosed everything that goes into the price of gas—the crude price, the wholesale price, the marketing margin, taxes, both provincial and federal, and, where applicable, how some municipalities impose their own gas tax.”

READ MORE: Conservative politicians fill up their gas-guzzlers

But the Ontario government turned down the CIPMA’s idea. It’s easy to see why. According to the province’s own website on motor fuel prices, the 125.5 cents per litre average price at the pumps last month was made up of 48.8 cents for crude oil, 28.9 cents for the wholesale margin, 6.3 cents for the retail margin, 10 cents for the federal excise tax, 14.7 cents for the Ontario tax, and 14.4 cents for the GST/HST shared by Ottawa and the province. The carbon tax was the thinnest slice of the price pie, at just 4.4 cents per litre.

In other words, for a driver who glanced at the pie chart while filling up, the carbon tax wouldn’t be the first thing to pop out. In fact, it might look modest by comparison to those other taxes and costs. By contrast, the stickers now being mailed to gas station owners by the Ford government show the federal carbon tax in isolation, illustrated by an upward swooshing arrow representing that planned increase in the levy, which is meant to discourage the carbon emissions that are the main culprit behind climate change.

“We are non-political by nature, but we do want consumers understanding everything that goes into the price of gas,” Stewart told Maclean’s. Still, she said her members, whose companies own more than 7,000 of Canada’s roughly 12,000 gas stations, have no plan to defy the law or challenge it in court.

The fines for refusing to put the stickers on the pumps by Aug. 30, as required under Ontario’s new Federal Carbon Tax Transparency Act, are steep—up to $500 each day for individuals, rising to up to $1,000 a day for subsequent offences, and up to $5,000 a day for corporations, doubling to up to $10,000 a day for subsequent offences.

“Our members as an association are going to do what the law indicates,” Stewart said. “We do feel that the messaging is a bit partisan in nature. It would be more beneficial if we painted a larger picture that shows all the components that go into the price of gas.” The timing of the Ontario sticker requirement coming into force is significant, since the Liberals’ carbon tax is being opposed by the federal Conservatives, and is expected to be a major point of debate is this fall’s federal election campaign.


Looking for more?

Get the Best of Maclean's sent straight to your inbox. Sign up for news, commentary and analysis.